Get the briefing by email: when the forecast moves and weekly through Election Day, then how our forecast did. See one

← Chart library

History · President, 1976–2024

When Third Parties Could Have Decided

In 1992, votes for candidates other than the two major-party nominees outnumbered the winning margin in forty-nine of the fifty states; in 2024, in two of fifty

Each column is a presidential election; each chip a state where the votes for every candidate other than the two major-party nominees added up to more than the gap between those two. In those states the others' votes exceeded the margin: enough, had they gone the other way together, to have changed the result. Below, the same count for Senate and governor races.

Swipe the chart sideways to see all of it.

Chip: state won by the DemocratChip: state won by the RepublicanOregon 1976: votes for others outnumbered the marginOROhio 1976: votes for others outnumbered the marginOHMaine 1976: votes for others outnumbered the marginMEVirginia 1976: votes for others outnumbered the marginVAIowa 1976: votes for others outnumbered the marginIAWisconsin 1976: votes for others outnumbered the marginWIMississippi 1976: votes for others outnumbered the marginMSCalifornia 1976: votes for others outnumbered the marginCAOklahoma 1976: votes for others outnumbered the marginOKWashington 1976: votes for others outnumbered the marginWA101976Massachusetts 1980: votes for others outnumbered the marginMAVermont 1980: votes for others outnumbered the marginVTHawaii 1980: votes for others outnumbered the marginHIMaine 1980: votes for others outnumbered the marginMEMinnesota 1980: votes for others outnumbered the marginMNNew York 1980: votes for others outnumbered the marginNYMaryland 1980: votes for others outnumbered the marginMDDelaware 1980: votes for others outnumbered the marginDERhode Island 1980: votes for others outnumbered the marginRIWisconsin 1980: votes for others outnumbered the marginWIArkansas 1980: votes for others outnumbered the marginARConnecticut 1980: votes for others outnumbered the marginCTOregon 1980: votes for others outnumbered the marginORTennessee 1980: votes for others outnumbered the marginTNAlabama 1980: votes for others outnumbered the marginALMichigan 1980: votes for others outnumbered the marginMIKentucky 1980: votes for others outnumbered the marginKYNorth Carolina 1980: votes for others outnumbered the marginNCSouth Carolina 1980: votes for others outnumbered the marginSCMississippi 1980: votes for others outnumbered the marginMSPennsylvania 1980: votes for others outnumbered the marginPAIllinois 1980: votes for others outnumbered the marginILWashington 1980: votes for others outnumbered the marginWAWest Virginia 1980: votes for others outnumbered the marginWV241980Minnesota 1984: votes for others outnumbered the marginMN1198401988Nevada 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginNVMontana 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginMTArizona 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginAZMaine 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginMEKansas 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginKSNew Hampshire 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginNHAlaska 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginAKWyoming 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginWYColorado 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginCOOhio 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginOHTexas 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginTXSouth Dakota 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginSDFlorida 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginFLWisconsin 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginWIIdaho 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginIDConnecticut 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginCTOregon 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginOROklahoma 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginOKIndiana 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginINNew Jersey 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginNJIowa 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginIAUtah 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginUTWashington 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginWANorth Carolina 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginNCGeorgia 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginGAMinnesota 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginMNDelaware 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginDEMichigan 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginMIMissouri 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginMONorth Dakota 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginNDKentucky 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginKYVirginia 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginVAPennsylvania 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginPALouisiana 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginLANew Mexico 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginNMCalifornia 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginCAVermont 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginVTNebraska 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginNESouth Carolina 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginSCRhode Island 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginRITennessee 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginTNMassachusetts 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginMAAlabama 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginALHawaii 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginHIWest Virginia 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginWVIllinois 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginILNew York 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginNYMississippi 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginMSMaryland 1992: votes for others outnumbered the marginMD491992Nevada 1996: votes for others outnumbered the marginNVMontana 1996: votes for others outnumbered the marginMTColorado 1996: votes for others outnumbered the marginCOKentucky 1996: votes for others outnumbered the marginKYSouth Dakota 1996: votes for others outnumbered the marginSDArizona 1996: votes for others outnumbered the marginAZNorth Dakota 1996: votes for others outnumbered the marginNDGeorgia 1996: votes for others outnumbered the marginGAVirginia 1996: votes for others outnumbered the marginVAIndiana 1996: votes for others outnumbered the marginINOregon 1996: votes for others outnumbered the marginOROhio 1996: votes for others outnumbered the marginOHMissouri 1996: votes for others outnumbered the marginMOTennessee 1996: votes for others outnumbered the marginTNFlorida 1996: votes for others outnumbered the marginFLOklahoma 1996: votes for others outnumbered the marginOKNorth Carolina 1996: votes for others outnumbered the marginNCTexas 1996: votes for others outnumbered the marginTXWisconsin 1996: votes for others outnumbered the marginWINew Mexico 1996: votes for others outnumbered the marginNMMississippi 1996: votes for others outnumbered the marginMSPennsylvania 1996: votes for others outnumbered the marginPANew Hampshire 1996: votes for others outnumbered the marginNHWyoming 1996: votes for others outnumbered the marginWYWashington 1996: votes for others outnumbered the marginWASouth Carolina 1996: votes for others outnumbered the marginSC261996Oregon 2000: votes for others outnumbered the marginORIowa 2000: votes for others outnumbered the marginIAWisconsin 2000: votes for others outnumbered the marginWIMinnesota 2000: votes for others outnumbered the marginMNNew Mexico 2000: votes for others outnumbered the marginNMNew Hampshire 2000: votes for others outnumbered the marginNHFlorida 2000: votes for others outnumbered the marginFLMaine 2000: votes for others outnumbered the marginMENevada 2000: votes for others outnumbered the marginNVOhio 2000: votes for others outnumbered the marginOH102000Wisconsin 2004: votes for others outnumbered the marginWINew Mexico 2004: votes for others outnumbered the marginNMIowa 2004: votes for others outnumbered the marginIA32004Missouri 2008: votes for others outnumbered the marginMOMontana 2008: votes for others outnumbered the marginMTNorth Carolina 2008: votes for others outnumbered the marginNCIndiana 2008: votes for others outnumbered the marginIN4200802012Utah 2016: votes for others outnumbered the marginUTMaine 2016: votes for others outnumbered the marginMEMinnesota 2016: votes for others outnumbered the marginMNNew Hampshire 2016: votes for others outnumbered the marginNHWisconsin 2016: votes for others outnumbered the marginWIMichigan 2016: votes for others outnumbered the marginMINevada 2016: votes for others outnumbered the marginNVColorado 2016: votes for others outnumbered the marginCONew Mexico 2016: votes for others outnumbered the marginNMPennsylvania 2016: votes for others outnumbered the marginPAArizona 2016: votes for others outnumbered the marginAZFlorida 2016: votes for others outnumbered the marginFLVirginia 2016: votes for others outnumbered the marginVANorth Carolina 2016: votes for others outnumbered the marginNC142016Arizona 2020: votes for others outnumbered the marginAZWisconsin 2020: votes for others outnumbered the marginWIGeorgia 2020: votes for others outnumbered the marginGANorth Carolina 2020: votes for others outnumbered the marginNC42020Wisconsin 2024: votes for others outnumbered the marginWIMichigan 2024: votes for others outnumbered the marginMI22024President: states where votes for anyone but the two nominees outnumbered the winning margin (chip colour: the state's winner)Senate2/334/323/333/363/334/347/342/354/321/334/33Governor1/115/360/119/362/128/353/125/360/113/360/11Senate and governor races from 2004 where others' votes outnumbered the margin, of that year's races won by a Democrat or a Republican with both parties running

How to read it. More than the margin is a measure of size, not a claim that those voters would otherwise have voted for the loser: they might have split, or stayed home. Washington, D.C., is left out. In the lower rows, a race counts only when both a Democrat and a Republican ran and one of them won; the margin there is between the two of them.

Source. MIT Election Data and Science Lab, U.S. President 1976–2024 (each nominee's votes on every ballot line); Senate and governor results as recorded by FutureBallot, November round, from 2004. Drawn November 2, 2026, 2:36 AM Pacific.

Link to this chartChart image pageDownload the data (CSV)Free to republish with credit to FutureBallot.